To evaluate progress and performance towards these strategic themes and targets, quantified performance measure indicators PMIs must be established in a specific and simple manner that allows all staff members to understand the orientation of the BSC in fulfilling their daily tasks. BSC conducting in higher education sector can be successful, and other management systems appliances are similar, must be supported by senior supervisors and cautious choice PMIs to assess the achievement of targets.
Chen, S. Emerald Group Publishing Limited. Please share your general feedback. You can start or join in a discussion here. Visit emeraldpublishing. Detailed analysis of individual health facilities revealed that hospital based health facilities strongly confounded the mean scores in the control sites as none had received the intervention but still scored very highly in most domains at baseline  and follow-up even in the absence of the intervention.
In recent times context has been recognised as an important factor that could affect even well designed clinical trials and currently there are efforts to standardise collection of contextual information in clinical trials. Our findings agree with these observations and support efforts to have contextual data considered in understanding the mechanism of change in trial settings  , .
The study had a number of limitations that must be considered when interpreting our findings. Firstly, the study was not powered to look for differences between sites or different types of facilities and therefore we will need to wait for final evaluation before any further interpretation of these findings. Secondly, the time from the implementation to the timing of this interim analysis was relative short. The longest intervention step had received the intervention for 12 months while the last step had received the intervention for 3 months only. This makes the comparison between control and intervention more complex requiring cautious interpretation.
We have tried to explore the effect of the intervention by time or step. However, the results remained inconclusive. It is therefore recommended to see the end line evaluation that includes a community survey to make concrete conclusions about the effect of the intervention.
Historically, Apple had been a technology- and product-focused company that competed by designing better computers. The objective should be to equip all employees with the right set of skills needed to consistently deliver high customer service on every call. Scorecards should be used to improve accountability through objective and performance measure ownership, and desired employee behaviors should be incentivized with recognition and rewards. It provides information on areas of strategic importance to guide future planning, but also serves as a snapshot of how well an organisation or system is performing . To offset this concern, we designed targets around long-term objectives. This is an area that is largely based on the nature of the trade or service that the company is into.
Some study results were based on observation of health workers and how they performed their duties in clinical setting. The fact that they were under observation could have altered their usual behaviour positively or negatively depending on what might be desirebale  , hence biasing the results of our study.
Similarly, exit interviews with clients could be influenced by this form of information bias . The study was done mainly in rural districts of Zambia were health system challenges might be different from urban settings. Therefore our findings could be more applicable to similar rural settings and may not be generalised to urban settings.
In addition, the study sites were fixed and limited to 42 health facilities based on what was available in the selected districts. This resulted in small sample size especially when performing stratified analysis by districts. This was worse in Luangwa district which had only 7 health facilities. This preliminary results show that the balanced scorecard approach can be useful in assessing the effects of complex public health interventions. Using system wide approaches and triangulating data collection methods seems to be key to successful evaluation of such complex intervention.
Browse Subject Areas? Click through the PLOS taxonomy to find articles in your field. Abstract Introduction In many low income countries, the delivery of quality health services is hampered by health system-wide barriers which are often interlinked, however empirical evidence on how to assess the level and scope of these barriers is scarce.
Results The study found significant mean differences between intervention I and control C sites in the following domains: Training domain Mean I:C; Conclusion This study demonstrates the utility of the balanced scorecard in assessing multiple elements of the health system. Trial number ClinicalTrials. Introduction In many low income countries, delivery of quality health services is hampered by system wide barriers which are often interlinked and their contribution to outcomes difficult to establish  , .
Methodology The BHOMA study is a cluster randomised community intervention that aims to strengthen the health system in three rural districts covering 42 health facilities in Zambia with a total population of , The District In each of the three districts, one Quality Improvement QI team is introduced that implements the intervention in target health facilities.
The Health Facility Intervention The health facility-based intervention aims to improve clinical care quality by implementing practical tools that establish clear clinical care standards, providing essential resources to meet these standards and communicating standards through intensive clinic implementations. Download: PPT.
Randomisation and Rollout Plans The 42 health facilities were randomised in the order of receiving the intervention in a step wedge fashion until all receive the intervention. Evaluation Design Baseline survey. Follow-up study. Results Health Facility Demographic Characteristics In total there were 42 health facilities which were randomly allocated to the intervention or control. Table 1. Summary of health facilities in the intervention and control sites stratified by districts.
Comparisons of Intervention and Control Health Facilities Mean scores were calculated for each domain in the balanced scorecard and these are shown in table 2. Table 2. Balanced scorecard measure of the effect of the BHOMA intervention after 12 months of implementation stratified by district. District Comparison of Intervention and Control Health Facilities In Chongwe district, significant mean differences between intervention and control sites were reported in training domain I:C; vs. Dose Dependence Effect of the Intervention We compared the effect of the intervention by time in the intervention phase.
Table 3. Balanced scorecard measure of the effect of the BHOMA intervention after 12 months of implementation stratified by timing of roll ou. Linear Regression Model Linear regression was done with the following dependent variables: Adult Clinical observation and service satisfaction scores, Children clinical observation and service satisfaction scores.
Application of Balanced Scorecard In Process Industry: A Case Study of Agro Base Company in Developing Country Prepared By: Umar. Learn how to set objectives, strategic goals and performance indicators in these three Balanced Scorecard examples.
Table 4. Linear regression analysis of the association between the different measures of quality of care. Discussion This study aimed to apply innovative approaches in evaluating a complex health system intervention and hence contribute to generation of empirical evidence to guide health system strengthening investments .
Conclusion This preliminary results show that the balanced scorecard approach can be useful in assessing the effects of complex public health interventions. Supporting Information. Tools S1. Calculation of health facility scores.
Tools S2. Adult Clinical observation checklist.
Tools S3. Children clinical observation checklist. Tools S4. Finance tool. Tools S5. Governance tool. Tools S6. Health worker motivation tool. Tools S7. Service satisfaction for adults and children. Checklist S1. Consort for cluster randomised Trial. Protocol S1. Published protocol. References 1.
Health Policy Plan 27 Suppl 4iv54— View Article Google Scholar 2. Implement Sci 6: View Article Google Scholar 3.
Health Policy and Planning iv1—iv3. View Article Google Scholar 4.
Health Policy PlosMedicine 7. English M, Schellenberg J, Todd J Assessing health system interventions: key points when considering the value of randomization. Bull World Health Organ — View Article Google Scholar 7. Paina L, Peters DH Understanding pathways for scaling up health services through the lens of complex adaptive systems. Health Policy Plan — View Article Google Scholar 8. Journal of Health Care Management 4.
View Article Google Scholar Kunz H, Schaaf T General and specific formalization approach for a Balanced Scorecard: An expert system with application in health care. Expert Systems with Applications — Harv Bus Rev 71— Health Policy — Using Business Process Portal Management module, users can change the performance targets and update the performance thresholds, worst and best values, and KPI relative weights; view KPI scores in a dashboard-like interface with selected indicators; and manage Balanced Scorecard applications. Business Process Server is best suited for defining and implementing the Balanced Scorecard management process.
This process includes defining KPI measures and performance targets, integrating with external systems to collect performance data, and providing a Balanced Scorecard interface for ease in monitoring KPIs.